This briefing paper examines some of the developments in 2002-2003 in court
procedures involving child sexual assault complainants. Methods of monitoring
convicted child sex offenders are also explored. Whilst the paper focuses on
initiatives in the New South Wales criminal justice system, comparisons are
made to other Australian jurisdictions and to the United Kingdom.
General principles and statistics – The sexual offence
provisions of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) are outlined, with guidance on
how they apply to child complainants. Information from organisations such as
the Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research and the Judicial Commission is
presented to indicate charge rates and types of penalties for child sexual
assault and the characteristics of offenders. Studies suggest that significant
attrition occurs between the reporting of alleged sexual offences against
children and the obtaining of convictions (pages 2-10).
Important reports – Findings are discussed from two reports
which have influenced recent legislative amendments, pilot projects, and
further plans for reform in New South Wales: The Experience of Child
Complainants of Sexual Abuse in the Criminal Justice System by Dr Christine
Eastwood and Professor Wendy Patton of the Queensland University of Technology,
released in July 2002; and the Report on Child Sexual Assault Prosecutions
by the New South Wales Legislative Council’s Standing Committee on
Law and Justice, tabled in November 2002 (pages 11-22).
Legislative changes – A range of statutory amendments that
commenced in 2003 are described, for example: the implementation of standard
minimum sentences for certain child sexual offences (among other serious
offences); the exemption of child sexual assault complainants from attending
committal proceedings; the exclusion of periodic detention as a punishment for
serious sexual offences, including sexual offences committed against children
under the age of 16 years; and clarification that when evidence-in-chief at
trial is given by a child in the form of a pre-recorded interview, it should
not be played to the court in the presence of the child (pages 23-28).
Specialist child sexual assault court – In March 2003 a pilot
program commenced that allows child sexual assault complainants to give
evidence by closed circuit television from a remote witness facility at
Parramatta, separate from the court house. Some of the other features of the
project are: a child-friendly environment; specialist training for judicial
officers involved in the pilot; a presumption in favour of using pre-recorded
evidence and other special measures; and pre-trial hearings to address the
needs of the child and reduce delays. The child sexual assault court is
intended to be less traumatic for children than conventional court proceedings
(pages 29-32).
Child sex offender registers – New South Wales established a
Child Protection Register under the Child Protection (Offenders
Registration) Act 2000 , and it has been operational since October 2001.
Persons found guilty of murdering a child or committing a sexual offence upon a
child must advise police of their personal, employment and motor vehicle
details, and their travel intentions. Offenders remain on the register for
between 8 years and life depending on the offence. The type of register
operating in New South Wales was influenced by the sex offender notification
requirements in the United Kingdom, which were introduced by the Sex
Offenders Act 1997 (UK). In Australia in September 2002, the Federal
Minister for Justice and Customs, Senator Chris Ellison, called upon the States
and Territories to set up child sex offender registers and develop consistent
legislation. In July 2003, the Australasian Police Ministers Council endorsed a
national approach, which would facilitate tracking child sex offenders across
borders and the exchange of information with other countries (pages 33-40).
Child sex offender orders – During the campaign for the State
election in March 2003, Premier Carr announced a plan to introduce child sex
offender orders in New South Wales, to restrict the movement of convicted
paedophiles in places frequented by children. Sex offender orders in the United
Kingdom were introduced by the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 and may be
issued against various sexual offenders by the Magistrates’ Court when it
is satisfied that an order is necessary to protect the public from serious
harm. The Sexual Offences Bill 2003 proposes to restructure sex offender
orders, creating three categories: Sexual Offences Prevention Orders, Risk of
Sexual Harm Orders, and Foreign Travel Orders. The Sexual Offences Bill passed
the House of Lords on 17 June 2003, and had completed the Committee stage in
the House of Commons at the time of writing (pages 41-43).
Paedophiles approaching children on the internet – The Carr
Government in March 2003 announced that it would create a new criminal offence
to target people who contact children on the internet with the ulterior motive
of sexually abusing them. The United Kingdom is in the process of introducing
the offence of ‘Meeting a child following sexual grooming’, which
will apply to an adult who meets (or travels with the intention of meeting) a
child under 16 years, if the adult has communicated with the child on at least
two previous occasions and intends to commit a sexual offence against the
child. The new offence is another initiative of the Sexual Offences Bill 2003
(pages 44-48).