Nominations: Wednesday, 16 December 1874, Polling: Friday, 18 December 1874
Candidate
Votes
Votes %
Arnold, William Munnings (Re-elected)
205
56.94
Brown, Herbert Harrington
155
43.06
Formal Votes
360
Informal Votes
0
0.00
Total Votes / Turnout
360
65.34
Persons Voting / Turnout
368
66.79
Source: Maitland Mercury report of nominations 17 December 1874, p.2 col.5-6, results 22 December, p.2 col.6-7, including booths. SMH report of nominations, 18 December 1874, pp.5-6, with results from SMH 23 December, p.7 col.3, including booth details. Vote discrepancy may be unreported informal votes.