Nominations: Tuesday, 13 October 1885, Polling: Friday, 16 October 1885
Candidate
Votes
Votes %
Fletcher, James (Re-elected 1)
2,483
42.24
Lloyd, George Alfred (Elected 2)
1,839
31.28
Ellis, James Cole (Defeated)
1,557
26.48
Formal Votes
5,879
Informal Votes
55
0.93
Total Votes / Estimated Turnout
5,934
68.68
Source: SMH 17 October 1885, p.10 col.2, with informal votes taken from Newcastle Herald, 17 October, p.2 col.4. No total of persons voting in Statistical Register or tabled papers.