Nominations: Friday, 18 December 1874, Polling: Monday, 21 December 1874
Candidate
Votes
Votes %
Cohen, Henry Emanuel (Re-elected)
343
49.21
Eckford, Joseph
196
28.12
Hamilton, Archibald Sellars
152
21.81
Farthing, William
5
0.72
Brooks, William
1
0.14
Formal Votes
697
Informal Votes
14
1.97
Total Votes / Turnout
711
67.91
Persons Voting / Turnout
711
67.91
Source: Report of nominations, SMH 21 December 1874, p.9 col.3-6, results from Maitland Mercury, 22 December 1874, p.2 col.7, also reported SMH 22 December 1874, p.5 col.3.