Nominations: Thursday, 16 December 1869, Polling: Friday, 17 December 1869
Candidate
Votes
Votes %
Campbell, James (Re-elected)
397
65.30
Keating, John
211
34.70
Formal Votes
608
Informal Votes
15
2.41
Total Votes / Turnout
623
75.88
Persons Voting / Turnout
623
75.88
Source: Report of nominations, 23 December 1869, p.3 col.3-6. Results taken from Maitland Mercury, 18 December 1869 in preference to the Empire or SMH as votes totals match details from Parliamentary Papers and Statistical Register sources.