Nominations: Tuesday, 26 January 1858, Polling: Tuesday, 9 February 1858
Candidate
Votes
Votes %
Hay, John (Re-elected 1)
432
45.47
Macleay, George (Re-elected 2)
407
42.84
Owen, Eugene
111
11.68
Formal Votes
950
Informal Votes
0
0.00
Total Votes / Estimated Turnout
950
53.43
Source: Report of nominations, SMH 5 February 1858, p.2 col.4-6, results 24 February, p.4 col.6 including booth details, reported as 'total result of the poll'. Full report of nominations, Yass Courier 6 February, p.4 col.1-4, ex-Border Post.